If the person speaks English, they can write in English. If not, they should write in their own language and you can submit that with an English translation and a certificate of translation (if you need info about the certificate of translation, I wrote about that on August 24, 2017). They can use a photo ID – whatever is a legit ID is fine, though for example if the person attended university with you, they might want to include the university ID to prove they were there at the same time as you. Take care, Jason

I am not sure how you can force them to identify themselves, and it seems to me that without showing their ID and a warrant, it is a lawless situation and there is a risk of criminals pretending to be ICE agents. Of course, criminals could also have pretend IDs and badges. Aside from asking to see a badge and warrant, I am not sure what else you can do. Maybe call a friend or a lawyer if you are in this situation, if you have a chance to do so. When the government acts this way, I am not sure what is the defense. Take care, Jason

Thank you very much for that information. Much appreciated

Thank you for your quick response, much appreciated.

Hello Jason. Thanks for your reply. I went over the ACLU documentation, but the document implicitly assumes that the encounter is with ICE or police (law enforcement) and then instructs what you can do. The problem is, how do we even know that the encounter is with law enforcement if they fail to show their identification or warrant? Like, imagine a hypothetical scenario where you are in a parking lot and a bunch of plain-clothed men and masked suddenly accost you, claiming to be federal/ice agents, and ask you not to resist and push you into an unmarked car. To be honest, this is no different from a kidnapping that happens in a 3rd world country. As a lawyer, what is the specific legal recourse to force the agents to identify themselves?

Good question. At least for your house, you do not have to let people in without a warrant (which I suppose could be fake). You might want to look at a “know your rights” document – the ACLU has a good one, which let’s you know what rights you have on the street, in your home, and elsewhere: https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/immigrants-rights
Take care, Jason

Yes, that is common, though in many cases, they call you and tell you that the decision is not ready and that they will mail it . Take care, Jason

Mike,

I did nothing except reminding them that the case is pending beyond the processing time. The applicants are my wife and kids as derivative asylee. I was the principal applicant years ago. RFE was for vaccine (medical).
Thanks

This is great! did you do anyhting to get your Greencard? did file for Mandamus?